I always thought I hated coffee. I used to choke some down while studying at Cafe Expresso trying to be cool a million years ago, but I wasn't fooling anybody. The truth was I hadn't experienced coffee in my preferred environment of rich sugarfied frozen grandness, the Frappe.
A few years ago I was working crazy hours out of town. Fourteen hours a day some days, I worked for over a year without a day off. Like The Boss, I had debts no honest man could pay. Anyway, in an attempt to pull it off I began frequenting these roadside drive through coffee barns with ridiculous names like Deja Brew. Names that made you want to walk in and slap the proprietor. There is this one place in Lake City called Elliano's owned by some religious group called the End Timers or the Time Shifters or something. Crazy as loons, but they made a mean Frappe. I like my Frappes like I like my women, full-bodied, earthy and complex, with a hint of
insouciance.That brings us to Coffee Culture on 13th st. The problem with their Frappe is that when I'm down to the last 1/3 the cup is mostly ice. A key to a winning coffee milkshake is an even ice to liquid ratio throughout the drinking experience. Coffee Culture's offering also contains a deceptively high amount of caffeine. Forty-five minutes later I'm hopping around like a ferret of amphetamines. This stuff actually gives me chest pains on a semi-regular basis. At work I have to be careful not to fly off the handle. They need to make a comedown Valium Frappe with a cough syrup chaser.
Next up in my comparative frozen coffee study was my old friend Dunkin Doughnuts. Let me lay down a couple of ground rules. All of my orders at various coffee shops must contain whipped cream and be mocha flavored. I may chose additional flavorings or stuff blended in. Anyway, back to Dunkin. They actually call their product a Coolata. It has a deeply synthetic taste. It is also the least creamy, most watery offering I've come across. Definitely not my first choice but ok in a pinch, especially if I'm in a life expectancy shortening mood and top off the order with a few Triple Chocolate Doughnuts.
Next door on Archer road is Starbucks. While their Frappucino is reasonably good I always marvel that they seem to employ three times as many people to serve coffee as Walgreens allows me to handle people's prescription needs. You've probably had a different experience, but I'm impressed with the staff's relentless cheerfulness at 7AM and their adherence to the workflow and script corporate Starbuck's has them maintain. As an experiment I'd like to hire these young people to work in my pharmacy for a month and see if it changed them. Maybe they could bring along their coffee machine and offer people Adderall expresso lattes.
So let's go back to examine what I think makes a Frappe great. First, I keep saying Frappe which I believe is technically incorrect from a European perspective. Basically they are coffee milkshakes. A lot of places in the U.S. call them Frappes. At Starbucks they are Frappucinos. At Dunkin they are Coolattas. Dairy Queen has a MooLatte. Everyone feels the need to put their little twist on the name.
Anyway a key ingredient is actually the size of ice. It must be very small, very hard particles of ice. If the ice is too slushy or too big you are left with major ice issues at the end of the drink. Do you really want to start your day at 8AM with major ice issues? Of course not. Ice that is the right size travels through the straw in a steady manner, and the drinker experiences a consistent texture throughout. Again, do you want to be left at the end sadly holding what amounts to a cup of ice yearning for more?
As mentioned, the Frappe must have whipped cream. This is not optional. It is also preferable that chocolate syrup is drizzled on top. Drizzle is a great word. Aside from being in the punch line to a Snoop Dogg joke it suggests a lazy opulence that is often missing from junk food in the fast food milieu.
Some places have variations in the main flavor. This is a coffee milkshake, stick with a mocha base. Sure you can get pumpkin truffle flambe, just realize you have taken an off ramp from coffee milkshake land.
Finally the Frappe is sweet, sure. Maybe even sickly sweet to some. But peel away that veneer and there is a seductive underbelly of darker and more tantalizing flavors. This is where you request additional flavoring to be added. It takes a special kind of alchemy to pull off the delicate balance. Starbucks seemed to have just the ticket for a while with the raspberry flavoring but I haven't been feeling it the last couple of times.
So I woke up early one morning and biked over to McDonalds before work to experience their McCafe Mocha. I was pretty hyped about this. There's been a buzz on the street about McDonald's coffee. It's consistency was more syrupy than most. It appears to be an intriguing amalgam of chemicals. There was no residual ice, but no tiny ice bits either. I got a weird sick to my stomach light headed jolt from it. Of course this was my fourth day in a row of having a Frappe for breakfast so maybe my mind was in the early stages of a caffeine, sugar and synthetic chemicals breakdown.
The next afternoon was my day off. I happened to be at Books a Million and on an impulse I walked over to their Joe Muggs coffee counter and bought a Candy Blast Frappe with Oreo. I must admit it had an impressive name. The server asked if I wanted extra chocolate. My motto in this scenario is if anyone asks if I want extra anything my answer is invariably hell yes. Anyway, it was better than I expected. Not very mocha-like even with the coffee base, but it had a nice pick me up. Good consistency. Not too watery, not too syrupy. Even tiny bits of ice.
My final tasting was the following morning at the Ben and Jerry's Caffeine Bar on Archer Rd. Ben and Jerry always struck me as being more stoned than hyped up on stimulants, but this place was mucho fun. They had board games, pajama parties, straight up ice cream and deserts. They cater to students who probably go there while partying on weekends to see if they can get their blood sugar level higher than their blood alcohol level. When I walked in to Ben and Jerry's I was hit with a rich sugar smell that can only be likened to that of Krispy Kreme or maybe the Publix Bakery when they're pumping out the good stuff. So I am saddened to report it's Mochachillo was rather pedestrian. It seemed like it was going to be awesome, mixing chocolate ice cream with coffee. The added cherry flavoring was lost in the mix. After a week of Frappes, it really had to distinguish itself. It wilted under the pressure, but I'm going back to B&J's. The place has tons of potential. Next time I'll try the Buzzachillo which is coffee ice cream with coffee, maybe hazel nut flavoring for kicks. They also have the Mt Everest of sundaes called the Vermonster, a 20 scoop behemoth that looks like it would scare straight even the most hardened junk food devotee.
Later at work that day I completely crashed. I was reduced to wandering around in a zombie like stupor. I slept about 14 hours that night.
So I'll probably have to scale back a bit because I am trying to eat healthier. I honestly don't know why because a few weeks ago I tried to cut way down on my junk food and my body thanked me by getting really sick for the first time well over a year. Virginia and I are going to start a garden. No, I will not be growing all sugar cane. Maybe I'll grow corn and start marketing a product called "Even Higher Fructose Corn Syrup." Hmm, that actually does sound awesome.